Blood test detects ovarian cancer in nine out of 10 patients 
November 19, 2015
Immunotherapy study gives lung-cancer patients hope
November 24, 2015
Show all

Pigeons spot cancer as well as human experts

Birds can be trained to find cancer in images of biopsies, with an accuracy rate of 99%. This is on par with that of human experts. By combining the “diagnosis” of multiple birds, this diagnosis rate even exceeds that of computer analysis in determining which biopsy image has cancer cells.

It may sound like a bird-brained idea, but scientists have trained pigeons to spot cancer in images of biopsied tissue. Individually, the avian analysts can’t quite match the accuracy of professional pathologists. But as a flock, they did as well as trained humans, according to a new study appearing this week in PLOS ONE.

Cancer diagnosis often begins as a visual challenge: Does this lumpy spot in a mammogram image justify a biopsy? And do cells in biopsy slides look malignant or benign? Training doctors and medical technicians to tell the difference is expensive and time-consuming, and computers aren’t yet up to the task. To see whether a different type of trainee could do better, a team led by Richard Levenson, a pathologist and technologist at the University of California, Davis, and Edward Wasserman, a psychologist at the University of Iowa, in Iowa City, turned to pigeons.

In spite of their limited intellect, the bobble-headed birds have certain advantages. They have excellent visual systems, similar to, if not better than, a human’s. They sense five different colors as opposed to our three, and they don’t “fill in” the gaps like we do when expected shapes are missing.

However, training animals to do a sophisticated task is tricky. Animals can pick up on unintentional cues from their trainers and other humans that may help them correctly solve problems. For example, a famous 20th century horse named Clever Hans was purportedly able to do simple arithmetic, but was later shown to be observing the reactions of his human audience. And although animals can perform extremely well on tasks that are confined to limited circumstances, overtraining on one set of materials can lead to total inaccuracy when the same information is conveyed slightly differently.

Read Full Article: Pigeons spot cancer as well as human experts | Science/AAAS | News

Comments are closed.